I'm generally a fan of graffiti. Nothing tells you a city, neighbourhood or space is lived in quite like a mosaic of tags, etchings, murals, stencils and pasties. Much of it takes amazing skill (try it sometime, spray cans aren't the most forgiving medium), and some of the most impressive artwork I've ever seen was done under cover of night under highways and train bridges. Since the first cave paintings, graffiti has remained a crucial form of cultural expression, coming even from the most marginalized sectors of society. It conveys messages, from the political to the pure and simple DM+CG 4EVR.
It is art.
It's not locked up in some pay-to-enter sterilized, carefully planned art gallery. It's not a sign of "high society" that one can show off to their friends at bourgeois cocktail parties or hang in their office to demonstrate their fat wallet and "high taste". It's not censored (except by other graffiti), it's not always liked and it certainly not always beautiful or polite, but a big black marker is about as free as expression gets when it comes to the written word.
Yes, some graffiti is used by gangs to mark their territory. But most isn't. And frankly, if your area's got a gang problem, you have bigger things to worry about (poverty, racism, hopelessness etc) than a few naughty lines. And yes, sometimes it's racist, but this, too, is rare, and nearly always is dealt with by other graffiti artists.
Does it make a neighbourhood look bad? It's funny how that argument doesn't hold for the Starbucks on Locke, or that hundred story Freudiansim that Harry Stinson wanted to build in the Howard Johnson parking lot. The fact is, the more you crack down, the worse graffiti you get.
Graffiti never goes away. I've traveled tens of thousands of kilometres and seen city after city. Not one had managed to eliminate graffiti. What many had, though, unlike our endless procession of tags which look like something from a third-grade lesson in cursive writing, was unbelievably beautiful and intricate murals. Taking a train out of any major station in Europe will give you at least a mile of pieces. Those never could have been done under crackdowns like the one we are experiencing at the moment, and wouldn't have been worth it if they could - they'd have been painted over. Tolerating some degree of public art, especially when it's in spaces like train yards which aren't trying to be beautiful anyways (in away, I'd agree, they are, but I'd say graffiti adds to that), why not let it be and focus on protecting spaces where it shouldn't be? I'll agree, nobody wants some joker to come by and bomb their garage, but big drab concrete pillars, postboxes (esp. those gray ones), train cars and are nobody's personal property. If somebody wants to go out and make the city more beautiful, then let's encourage them - if it's beautiful, let it stay - the best guarantee of not getting tagged is a big, nice mural (commissioned or not). We should explicitly decriminalize artwork on a certain class of public space (not a handfull of "public walls") - bare, boring walls, sidewalk tiles, highway overpasses and the like. Set people free to express themselves.
Cracking down does nothing but scare away the real artists. Good graffiti, like good oil painting or sculpting, takes time. Nobody wants to be busted, and nobody wants 30 hours of their work painted over, or to be tied to a truly remarkable set of tags. Since nature abhors a vacuum, others will step in to fill it, and that's where you get some of the crap which adorns our city. Someone will always step in. The answer to this crackdown? Chillen. Big, bold blasts of paint tagging his name in 20-30 foot letters, as well as his ubiquitous tags on every bus shelter in sight. One colour, no finesse, just a great big fuck you to everyone in charge.
Graffiti artists have a responsibility here too. The public is not going to support graffiti until it sees something it likes, and in general, it doesn't. As much of a fuck-you as the 10-billion Keenur tags around town were, they don't add much to public space. Paint something beautiful, informative or thoughtful, or at least something that encourages other people to get involved.
Ultimately, to me, it's the romance that does it. A dark night with a black hoodie and a bag full of cans, so quiet you can hear your heart pounding and just waiting to see the cherry lights of a cruiser swing around the corner at any time. The graffiti artist is a person who puts his own freedom on the line to give art to the world...can you claim as noble a purpose?
So this post goes out to Keenur, with the best of hopes for your trial, and for all the others caught up in the city's latest "cleanup". This goes out to Chillen, for being big, bold and loud. It goes out to everyone who's ever stayed up late cutting stencils out of old cereal boxes and everyone who knows just how loud that little ball bearing can be when you're shaking a can on a cold, dark and deathly quiet night. And, with all the love and thanks I can muster, it goes out to everyone who ever helped me keep from getting bored in an otherwise unremarkable toilet stall.